Did you ever dip the bow under water during your ride back in? It seems these short boats will do that a lot. I know the last time I was out in 3 and 4 footers the wave period was short and the nose of my Alumacraft kept going under. That made for a miserable ride back to the ditch and safety. Heck it went under some when at trolling speed when we still had lines out. I think a 19 footer would be a much better all around boat length for fishing this lake. If I could do things over that is what I would have done.
Not really too bad - did get a few come over the front but I wouldnt say I dipped it under. When I get in bad waves I trim the engine to bring the nose up some to keep it from nose diving as much as possible. A 19 would be better for the big lake but I also run to smaller lakes and once you go above 17' everything gets a lot more expensive (larger motor, hydraulic steering, trailer brakes, etc). So far I do not regret my boat for how I use it and where I go with it but that is just a personal thing. 17 is the smallest I would want to be out any distance on the big lake with.
-Eddo-
2014 Alumacraft competitor 175 aka "The Geek Squad"
The South End provides useful resources and discussion forums for those that fish The South End of Lake Michigan for Salmon, Steelhead, Perch, and Bass as well as elsewhere in the Region and Chicago area.